GROUP D - NATIONAL ICONS
Winner: Cohiba Rubicon Box-Pressed Robusto
Match M19 opened Group D with two contrasting Honduran and Nicaraguan expressions. Cohiba Rubicon Box-Pressed Robusto entered as the Ashologist.com Wild Card, while Casa Magna Colorado Pikito brought a compact Nicaraguan puro and an established national name.
Rubicon is the medium-bodied 5.5 x 55 box press with an Ecuadorian Habano wrapper, U.S. Broadleaf binder, and Dominican, Honduran, and Nicaraguan fillers. Quesada's current page confirms the Pikito as a 4.75 x 42 Nicaraguan puro with a Cuban-seed, shade-grown Colorado wrapper from Jalapa.
Cohiba won the approved M19 matchup 28.5 to 27.5. Casa Magna delivered immediate concentration, but Rubicon produced the more complete progression and a more composed finish. Cohiba opened Group D at 1-0, while Casa Magna began 0-1.
Matchup at a Glance
| Category | Cohiba Rubicon Box-Pressed Robusto | Casa Magna Colorado Pikito |
|---|---|---|
| Manufacturer | Cohiba - General Cigar Company / Forged Cigar Company | Casa Magna - Quesada Cigars |
| Origin | Honduras | Nicaragua |
| Wrapper | Ecuadorian Habano | Nicaraguan Colorado, Cuban-seed shade-grown from Jalapa |
| Binder | U.S. Broadleaf | Nicaraguan |
| Filler | Dominican Piloto, Honduran La Entrada and Jamastran, Nicaraguan Estelí | Nicaraguan |
| Factory | STG Danlí, Honduras | Not listed on Quesada's current product page |
| Vitola | Box-Pressed Robusto, 5.5 x 55 | Pikito, 4.75 x 42 |
| Strength | Medium | Medium to full |
| Qualifying price | Exact qualifying MSRP must be reconfirmed before publication | Approximately $7.72 per cigar in the approved tournament profile |
| Profile score | 29.5/30 - Legendary | 27.0/30 - Very Good |
Official M19 score
28.5/30 - Winner
27.5/30 - Loss
Layered Polish vs. Compact Nicaraguan Intensity
Rubicon opened with cedar, cocoa, roasted coffee, and mild sweetness through a controlled draw. Toasted cedar, espresso, and measured black pepper established the first third. Leather, earth, walnut, and natural sweetness then added depth before dark coffee, seasoned oak, cocoa, and refined pepper carried a long finish.
Casa Magna began with cedar, cocoa, pepper, and earth through a compact, controlled draw. Black pepper, toasted cedar, earth, and cocoa arrived quickly. Espresso, roasted nuts, and natural sweetness added balance in the middle before oak, coffee, and firmer pepper closed the smoke.
The Pikito created faster concentration and a firmer spice line. Rubicon covered more ground: coffee, cocoa, cedar, leather, earth, walnut, oak, sweetness, and pepper developed in distinct stages. That broader sequence gave the opener its one-point separation.
Where Match M19 Was Decided
The standing profiles rate Cohiba Rubicon Box-Pressed Robusto at 29.5/30 - Legendary. Construction, draw, flavor complexity, balance, and finish are 5.0; burn is 4.5. Casa Magna Colorado Pikito is rated 27.0/30 - Very Good. All six standing profile categories are 4.5.
Official M19 score: Cohiba Rubicon Box-Pressed Robusto 28.5, Casa Magna Colorado Pikito 27.5.
The official M19 result is a match-specific score. Cohiba's 28.5 total is one point below its 29.5 standing profile, while Casa Magna's 27.5 is half a point above its 27.0 profile. The approved archive does not publish a separate M19 category card, so no category margin is assigned or reverse-engineered.
Both standing profiles show high-level construction and balance. The approved competition record describes Casa Magna's concentrated Nicaraguan richness as a serious challenge, while Rubicon's broader progression, layered finish, and composed presentation produced the more complete M19 performance.
Official Result: Cohiba Rubicon Box-Pressed Robusto Wins M19
Cohiba Rubicon Box-Pressed Robusto defeated Casa Magna Colorado Pikito 28.5 to 27.5 and moved to 1-0 in Group D. The Wild Card's first appearance established the complexity and control that would define its group campaign.
Casa Magna moved to 0-1 after a credible one-point loss. Its compact format delivered dense Nicaraguan flavor and dependable mechanics, but Rubicon created more development from opening cedar and cocoa through its coffee-and-oak finish.
Final Ashology Verdict
Casa Magna Colorado Pikito delivered cedar, cocoa, black pepper, earth, espresso, roasted nuts, natural sweetness, and oak with impressive concentration for a 4.75 x 42 cigar.
Cohiba Rubicon delivered the more complete M19 smoke. Its controlled box press carried cedar, cocoa, espresso, leather, earth, walnut, sweetness, oak, and refined pepper through clearer transitions and a longer finish.
Tasting notes reflect the exact cigars and vitolas evaluated for the 2026 Value Cigar Championship. Current product specifications were checked against official manufacturer information. Flavor, strength, draw, and burn may vary with storage, age, production variation, and individual palate. Tobacco products are intended only for adults of legal smoking age.
Value Cigar of the Year
Where Quality Meets Affordability